Cafe

Open-ly speaking with Hartosh

Hartosh Singh Bal is the Political Editor of ‘The Caravan’ and the author of ‘Waters Close over Us: A journey along the Narmada’. He was formerly the political editor of ‘Open’ – a position he was sacked from for filing stories that were deemed too critical of members of the present government. Café got the author talking on his trip to Goa for the Writers and Readers Festival which concluded recently

Herald Team

Herald Cafe: You are here for this festival, what is your assessment of it?

Hartosh Singh Bal: It is always interesting to come and interact with an audience and understand what is going on here. It was interesting to meet so many people from all over the country as well as expats from all over the world. It would have been nice though to meet some Goans and talk to them. There are so many such festivals around the country and it is nice to come to Goa for something similar.

HC: You left the magazine ‘Open’ not under ideal circumstances. What is the status right now of your fight for justice?

HSB: Well I was sacked, so yes it was not ideal. I am currently in a legal battle with ‘Open’. They had initially offered me a settlement of Rs 20 lakhs but I turned it down because I wanted to see what their reason for sacking me was. I was aware that there were murmurings in the office that calls had been received by the senior management following an article I had filed. I refused the payout and was sacked. I had signed a contract with the company but that contract cannot violate the working journalists act. I was told there was a difference of vision which is crazy because no vision was shared with us anytime during my tenure. I filed a complaint and we went to court. We shall see how it goes.

HC: What do you make of the current government’s relationship with the media?

HSB: Well, it is the culmination of a process which began with the Congress. The selection of certain journalists who were then given exclusives and access to senior politicians was started by the Congress. The BJP with Modi at the helm are much more effective. The behaviour of the media has been appalling; look at the way they have covered the visit to the USA. It has been a visit where nothing has been achieved but you would not think that reading the accounts. The ideology of this government which demonises the Muslim and the Christian is appalling but how many media houses have questioned it since this government has come to power?

SCROLL FOR NEXT